Crème Ice Cream Co.
(479) 222-1841 Gift Cards Order & Hours

Home / Menu

40+ Flavors, Made In-House

Homemade ice cream, Italian ice, and dairy-free desserts — small-batch, rotating, and worth checking before you go. Here's what makes the lineup genuinely different.

Signature Flavors

The Ones People Come Back For

Signature

Possum Pie

A real Southern classic turned into a scoop — genuinely unusual for the category, and not something you'll find at a national chain.

Signature

Saffron Pistachio

Floral, nutty, and nothing like the standard scoop-shop menu — genuinely unusual for the category.

Rotating

Seasonal Specials

The full 40+ flavor lineup rotates — call ahead or stop by to see what's scooping today.

The Regulars

Our Flavor Lineup

The full case rotates and changes often — call ahead to check what's scooping today.

Ice Cream

23 flavors
Ugandan Vanilla Ecuadorian Chocolate Salted Caramel Crunch Biscoff Crumble Banana Puddin' Cookie Dough Brownie Batter Cotton Candy Classic Pistachio Saffron Pistachio Mint Chip Reese's Supreme Oreos & Cream Strawberry Cheesecake * Blueberry Banana Nut Muffin Taro * Matcha Coffee Grounds Himalayan Chai Southern Cornbread Possum Pie Bourbon Pecan Horchata

Seasonal Ice Cream

6 flavors
Fayetteville Funfetti Keylime Cheesecake Briar Rose's Cinnamon Roll Camo Miso Dreamin' Butter Beer

Italian Ice

14 flavors
Lemon Piña Colada Mango Strawberry Watermelon Banana Juicy Fruit Sour Cherry Cotton Candy Bubble Gum * Tiger's Blood * Blue Raspberry * Green Apple * Cherry *

Dairy-Free Ice Cream

4 flavors
DF Salted Caramel DF Chocolate Mint Oreos DF Banana Cream DF Coconut

* contains artificial flavor or coloring

Straight Off The Board

What It Costs

Classics

Classics pricing
Single Scoop$5
Double Scoop$7
Waffle Cone (add-on)+$1
Cake Cone (add-on)+$0.50
Pint, 16oz$9
Quart, 32oz$17

Italian Ice

Italian Ice pricing
Small$3
Medium$5
Large$7

Specialties

Specialties pricing
Biscoff Sandwich — Ugandan Vanilla ice cream between 2 Biscoff cookies$2.50
Float — any flavor + soda$7.50
Milkshake — any flavor + whipped cream, add coffee for $1$7.50
DF Milkshake — dairy-free ice cream w/ housemade oat milk$8
Sundae — any flavor w/ sauce & whipped cream$8
Affogato — any flavor + drip coffee$8
Affogato Sundae — coffee, sauce, whipped cream & crumble$9
Mangonada — mango ice + chamoy, tajín, Mexican candy$8
Ice Cream Flight — any 6 flavors$17
Ice Cream Nachos — 2 flavors + sauce, whipped cream, waffle chips$10
The ARK — 2 scoops of every flavor & every topping$143
Toppings +$1 Each
Sweet Dark Chocolate White Chocolate Caramel Biscoff Marshmallow Peanut Butter Cherry Oreos Crumble Biscoff Crumble CC Cookies Crumble Baby Nerds Sour Powder Housemade Vanilla Whip Housemade Salted Caramel Whip

Menu and pricing sourced directly from the shop's own posted menu — always confirm in-store, as flavors rotate.

Can't Decide?

Try The Ice Cream Flight

A curated tasting lineup in one sitting — reviewers call this out as one of the reasons a visit here is a stop, not just a stop-and-go. Ask in-store to build yours.

Pair it with a table game while you decide on seconds — every table has one.

Local Collabs

Made With NWA Neighbors

Special flavors and pairings made with Bloom Cheese Co. and Briar Rose Bakery — real local partners, not a syrup catalog. Watch the menu for the next collab drop.

Order Ahead Or Stop By

Pickup or delivery, or walk in at 2730 N College Ave.

Order Pickup Order Delivery
Get Hours & Directions Call (479) 222-1841

A Note From Kuhio Palms

Your Flavors, Front And Center

This is what a real on-site menu looks like — no more sending people to Instagram to find out what's in the case. $399 gets your real site started, live within 72 hours.

Claim This Site — $399 To Start